It’s a reasonable thing to wonder: why save a troubled tooth when you could replace it? The two paths involve very different steps, and the condition of your own tooth largely decides which one fits.
Let's find a time
A root canal tries to keep your natural tooth in place by treating the inside of it. An implant comes after a tooth has been lost or removed, using a post placed in the jawbone to carry a replacement. They aren’t two versions of one procedure, and they’re suited to different situations.
Rivercrest is outside the City of Winnipeg, and either route could mean more than one planned trip to our McPhillips Street clinic. Before you pick a favourite, have the tooth examined. If enough healthy structure and support remain, preserving it may be on the table; if not, the conversation moves to removal and what might follow.
Explore root canal therapy
A general preference can’t tell you what’s possible. An exam of the actual tooth can.
Compare each path from beginning to end, including healing and final restoration, instead of only the first step.
Removal alone isn’t the whole bill if you later plan on replacing what was taken out.
These summaries are for orientation only. Suitability for either one comes from an assessment, and your dentist may have reasons to favour one for your particular mouth.
Treatment works inside the existing tooth. Keeping it avoids creating a gap and helps preserve your normal chewing, provided a predictable restoration can be made.
Extraction may be more suitable when a tooth is fractured too deeply or lacks the support to hold a repair. An implant is one possible replacement to discuss afterward.
Neither path can promise a permanent result. Ask how each one might do in your case, and what its likely upkeep would look like.
An even-handed comparison takes more than a general description of each treatment. This is one way of working through your choice at the clinic.
Request your visitMention in your request that you’re considering both options. It’s useful for the clinic to know from the outset what you’re weighing.
After the exam and X-rays, ask how the tooth’s condition, support and long-term outlook affect the likelihood of keeping it.
Find out what each route would involve, including healing periods and restorations, so you can compare how many visits each may take.
Consider cost, timing, your other teeth and how you feel about each option. Then make your decision with the dentist’s findings in hand.
Avoid asking only which one is better. More specific questions about your own tooth and situation tend to bring you more useful answers.
Since appointments mean coming in from Rivercrest, ask how the number and spacing of trips would differ between the two options.
A white desk with a clear divider, and a long blue chair under a white overhead arm.
You may be drawn to an implant simply because you dread a root canal. If so, say that plainly, as the concern itself can be discussed apart from the choice.
Your tooth is numbed first, though you might sense some pressure or vibrating. Sharp pain is always something to speak up about.
Ask how the area is numbed and what healing might feel like, so you can compare accurately.
A fear of one procedure is legitimate information. It simply shouldn’t be the only thing that makes your decision.
Living with the choice
A restored natural tooth and a replacement both need looking after. It’s helpful to ask about the long view for each before you finalize your decision.
Short-term biting tenderness can happen, and it should be easing as time goes on. Call the clinic if pain or swelling is worrying or growing.
Ask for specific aftercare instructions, and find out how long you should wait before any replacement could go ahead.
Either option benefits from regular dental visits, as new problems can develop around treated teeth and replacements alike.
Treated teeth can still develop new decay or a fracture, so keep this tooth on your list for regular care if you keep it.
Talk with our team
Winnipeg North Dental
Unit-5 2358 Mcphillips Street, Winnipeg, MB R2V 4J6Get directions (opens in a new tab)If you’re coming in from Rivercrest, your appointments would be at Winnipeg North Dental, Unit 5, 2358 McPhillips Street, in Winnipeg.
Filling in the form only starts the conversation, and an appointment is settled once staff have been in touch with you.
Questions about coverage?
Talk with our team before your visit or learn about CDCP.
Helpful details about root canal therapy in Rivercrest.
Ask our teamUse the form on this page or call (204) 338-3003, and say you’d like to compare a root canal with removing the tooth. Assessments happen at our McPhillips Street clinic in Winnipeg, and staff will confirm timing.
Newer isn’t the deciding factor. A root canal keeps your own tooth when that’s realistic, and an implant is one way to replace a tooth that can’t be kept.
No one can give a single answer that holds for everybody. Your tooth’s condition, your bone, your bite and your ongoing care all play a role, so ask how those apply to you.
Compare the whole plan, not just the first step. Include the removal, the timing, every procedure involved in the replacement, and the crown a saved tooth may also need.
Treating the tooth now doesn’t automatically rule out a later replacement, but future suitability can’t be promised. Raise this directly, because it depends on your bone and on how the tooth fares.
These pages go into more depth on removing a tooth, replacing it with an implant and the crown that frequently follows a root canal.
Learn how dental implants in Winnipeg can replace one tooth or support bridges and dentures, including candidacy, placement, healing and restoration.
Explore serviceLearn when a tooth extraction may be needed in Winnipeg, what happens during the visit, how to prepare for recovery and which replacement options may follow.
Explore serviceLearn how custom dental crowns in Winnipeg protect cracked, worn or root canal-treated teeth while restoring comfortable function, shape and appearance.
Explore serviceHave an urgent concern? Call (204) 338-3003 to discuss availability.
Still deciding?
Request a visit at our Winnipeg clinic, and staff will reply to arrange timing. Call instead if the tooth is causing severe pain or swelling.
Patient testimonials
Winnipeg North Dental
“Excellent experience at Winnipeg North Dental. Recommended by my friend Gagandeep. The whole staff is professional and attentive. Special thanks to my friend there. Highly recommend!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Had a great experience at Winnipeg North Dental. My hygienist, Haven, was thorough, professional, and gave really useful recommendations. Watching Netflix during the cleaning was an awesome bonus. Dr. Elzayat was great as well. Overall, a smooth, comfortable visit. Highly recommend!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I really enjoyed the treatment at this clinic. I had my teeth treated by Dr. Sukhpreet. Everything went great. Thank you so much for your professionalism!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Dr harpreet and Dr. Sidhu both were very nice during the job , full professional, very knowledgeable and Dr Harpreet was really polite during all time .”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I had a great experience at Dental North in Winnipeg for a teeth cleaning. The staff was friendly and professional, and the hygienist was gentle yet thorough. I left with my teeth feeling amazing and will definitely be returning!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Very quick, efficient and friendly. Very happy to have found this place.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I did called them in 2020 October they were not opened at that time. I give them my number, email and name so that when they open they can give me call to book appointment. They might have forgot that. I had a first appointment for dental in Canada. It went really good. They explained every single bit what they gonna do, What is best for me, Doctor was really nice. It was completely satisfying experience. Didnt smell like a clinic. I mean like any walk in doctor clinic. Even they helped me to understand my dental benefits to use them in best possible way. I would definitely recommend to others.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Excellent experience! The dentist and staff were professional, friendly and were very welcoming!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I had a great experience at this place, dr Sidhu and all the team was great.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“They are honest and know what they are doing. i came here for my 7 year old dental treatment and Dr sukhpreet guide us very nicely and did perfect job .Its a feeling in safe hands. Reception and staff are polite .”
Winnipeg North Dental
“My recent visit at the Winnipeg North Dental was excellent. The staff was friendly, the cleaning was thorough yet gentle, and the dentist took the time to explain everything clearly. I highly recommend them! Dr Sidhu is awesome:)”
Winnipeg North Dental
“It was really great experience with Dr. Jiwan on my first visit. She treated me very nicely and professionally . Staff were very nice and friendly.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Excellent clinic with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Dr. Sidhu handled my tooth issue very gently and in a friendly, professional manner — truly one of the best!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Friendly staff, clean clinic, and a dentist who really cares. Everything was explained clearly and I felt comfortable the whole time. Highly recommend”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I had great experience at this place all the staff was really helpful and professional.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I have had nothing but wonderful experiences with Winnipeg North Dental. I have brought my child here for teeth cleaning and she loves how kindly the entire staff treat her. Dr. Sidhu is kind, professional, and extremely thorough. I highly recommend!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Dr. Sidhu is so kind and caring. Her gentle approach makes going to the dentist a pleasure especially for a child. My daughter and I are so happy we found Winnipeg North Dental. The staff are great too! Highly recommend.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“This place is immaculate, friendly, helpful and the people working there are wonderful! Dr. Sidhu is the BEST!!!! She really cares about you and making your dental experience a positive one! Forever a patient!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Dr. Sidhu exhibits a high level of professionalism and offers exceptional accommodation. She is an outstanding physician who consistently provides assistance with any dental pain or issues that I have encountered. I am grateful for her expertise and support.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Dr Sidhu is very friendly and kind she takes care of her patients very well. I have my first visit yesterday and she listen and understand my problems and have done a good examination. Also suggested me many things which can improve my teeth situation. The staff is also very good and helpful. I will be visiting there again for sure.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I had wonderful experience at this place. Thanks to the whole team.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I have always found Dr. Sidhu to be very patient and comforting as well as gentle and makes for a totally painless visit, when ever I have dental issues. She is a very up beat and positive person which makes for great dental work experience every time.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I had a wonderful experience! Dr Sidhu and her team are always so friendly. It was also my 1 year old daughters first check up and Dr. Sidhu was so kind and patient with her. I highly recommend Winnipeg North Dental. Kind, passionate, professional and very well managed. So happy I found such a great dentist!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Recently, i had received two treatments and feeling very good and would like to thank the doctor for explaining in details about the problem and procedure . I would like to thank the staff and doctor for their professionalism for providing the kind service.Thank you.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“My experience here was amazing. Dr. Jiwan Sidhu is very nice and kind! She's overall a great dentist and I recommend others to come here!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Dr. Sidhu and her Winnipeg North Dental Team are AWESOME!!! They always make their client feel comfortable and explains everything that need to be done in every visit. I also like that she is very caring, always connect with us after our visit to ensure that all is well with our teeth. Very highly recommended.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Dr Sukhpreet has great and professional knowledge . God bless”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Dr. Sidhu is an amazing doctor who makes her patients feel comfortable and guides through the process. Me and my family had a great experience. I love the way she shares all details about dental health. Thank you”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Amazing place. It is always clean. And Dr.Sidhu takes very good care of her patients. Every time I am there she goes above and beyond to make my stay a pleasant one. Dr.Sidhu truly cares about her patients as do the other staff working with her. They are all very professional. I highly recommend this place and dentist.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I can't wait to get in the chair with Dr. Sidhu looking down on me with that super powerful freezy needle. Oh yeah, nicest dentist I've ever been to in all of my 79 years. She makes pain fun!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Dr. Sidhu and her team are amazing. Everyone is very welcoming and know how to make a client comfortable. She explains everything about the procedure and follows up after every session. I am glad I visited her for regular check ups.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Called first thing in the morning for an emergency and my 4 year old son was taken in within an hour. Dr. Sukhpreet was so nice and gentle and my son just adored her. Just the best dental office for my family..!!!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“My wife and I have been going to Dr.Sidhu and Maribeth for a very long time now. Over 10 years. And when Winnipeg North Dental started we followed them there. The care we get there is the best. From the front desk staff, to the hygienist and dental assistants and the dentists they’re the best group. Thank you guys.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Knowledgeable staff and easy to get appointments! Thanks”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Just started going to this Clinic and so far my experience are all positive. Staff are friendly. Clinic is super clean. Very organized and always on time. Plenty of parking.Highly recommended”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Dr. Sidhu and her staff are amazing! They don't rush, ask questions, and take the time to answer. I was impressed that Dr. Sidhu spent more than 10 minutes doing my check-up; the last dentist I went to spent 2 minutes and didn't even ask my name! I will definitely be going back.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“I’ve been seeing Dr.Sidhu at Winnipeg North Dental since it opened! Always a 10/10 experience there! She and all her staff exceed my expectations every time! Extremely friendly and will go the extra mile for you to ensure you receive the best dental care possible!”
Winnipeg North Dental
“My experience in Winnipeg North dental was amazing and thankyou to Dr. Sidhu and her team , they also ensure that the patient in their care always feel comfortable. They provide the best quality service to their patients and Dr. Sidhu is amazing , very friendly. Highly recommended.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Wonderful experience with Winnipeg North Dental Clinic. Dr. Sidhu was a wonderful dentist, and the staff was always helpful and kind. They ensured I had a smooth process and follow-up. I am so glad I chose Winnipeg North Dental clinic and would highly recommend to anyone.”
Winnipeg North Dental
“Had a cleaning that was great! All staff are awesome also had a filling done with Dr Sidhu her bed side manner and pt care is top notch! When she did the freezing needle I could not feel any pain! Absolutely none! If you have any fear of dentists Dr. Sidhu is for you!!”
Close to home
Convenient dental care on McPhillips Street for families across northwest Winnipeg and nearby communities.
Explore all service areasNeighbourhoods & communities
Nearby streets & corridors
A healthier smile is one visit away
